Fill it with their own stuff, slightly nicer. The lip balm they already use, a pen that writes properly, the candy they always grab at the checkout. Then add one fun thing.
The big present's sorted. Then there's the stocking, and that's where it goes wrong. It's late, you're tired, and somehow a fish-shaped bottle opener ended up in your basket.
Everything below costs under $25, most of it under $10. Pick three or four and you're done.
Under $10
Most of the stocking should come from here. Boring? A little. But boring stuff gets used, and the plastic surprise is in the trash by New Year's.
Vaseline Lip Therapy Mini, Cocoa Butter
$3.49Tiny pot, smells like cocoa, lives in a coat pocket until March. Everyone's lips are cracked by January anyway. See Vaseline Lip Therapy.
Skip if They hate scented lip stuff.
Pilot G2 Gel Pens, 4-pack
$7–$8The pen people quietly steal from each other at work. Give them four of their own. See Pilot G2 4-pack.
Skip if They only write on their phone.
Prices are rough US estimates. Check the shop before ordering.
A few more:
- Their favorite candy, $3–$8. The exact one they grab at the checkout, not the fancy gift-shop version of it.
- Hair ties or clips, $5–$10. Only the kind they already use. Wrong size goes straight in a drawer.
- Gum or mints, $2–$5. Zero excitement, always gets used. Get their flavor.
For her
She doesn't need a self-care kit in a pink box. A better version of something she already uses every day does the job.
eos Cashmere Lip Butter, Vanilla Cashmere
$6.99Thicker than normal lip balm and smells like vanilla frosting. If she's a lip balm person, this one comes everywhere with her. See eos Lip Butter.
Skip if She hates scented lip stuff.
Also good:
- Mini hand cream, $5–$12. Her usual brand, or fragrance-free. Winter hands are rough.
- A claw clip, $5–$12. If her hair's up most days, she can always use one more. Match her size and color.
- A fancy snack, $5–$15. Good chocolate, salted nuts or something from that bakery she likes.
For him
Skip the bottle opener. He has three and doesn't know where any of them are.
If he fixes stuff, carries a pocket tool or always has a tangled cable in his bag, you've got options.
Victorinox Classic SD
$24Scissors, nail file and a tiny blade, small enough for a keyring. He'll use it every week and never think about it. See Victorinox Classic SD.
Skip if He flies a lot (security will take it) or he's a kid.
Cheaper ones:
- A cable organizer, $5–$10. For the guy whose bag is half charging cables.
- His coffee beans, $10–$20. The bag he already buys. Check the grind if he's picky about his setup.
- Boot laces, $5–$12. Sounds weird, gets used. Check the length first.
For kids and teens
Skip the five tiny toys. They'll break before New Year's. Get one thing they'll actually play with.
Schylling NeeDoh Nice Cube
$6–$10A squishy cube that's way more satisfying than it should be. Teens keep it on the desk and squeeze it through homework. Find NeeDoh Nice Cube.
Skip if For kids under 3, or anyone who'll bite it.
More:
- Stickers from whatever they're into, $4–$10. That changes every month, so check first.
- A small LEGO polybag, $5–$10. A ten-minute build on Christmas morning. Check the age range.
- A mini card game, $6–$15. Something to play with cousins over the break. Make sure they don't own it.
What not to put in a stocking
If you're buying it because the stocking still looks empty, put it back.
- Plastic novelty stuff that's funny for five seconds.
- Random mini makeup when you don't know what they use.
- Gadgets that need weird batteries.
- One big multipack split up to look like more gifts.
- Small loose parts for little kids.
How much to put in a stocking
No rule here. Three to six things is normal if there's a bigger present too.
Some families do candy and socks and call it a day. That's fine. It's not a second round of presents.
Remember what they actually like
People tell you the small stuff all year. They're out of their good pens, they love those mints, their lip balm's nearly gone. By December you've forgotten all of it.

Save it in Giftin the day they say it, so you're not guessing in December.
Get Giftin freeQuick answers
What are good stocking stuffers for adults?
Their own everyday stuff, slightly nicer. Lip balm, good pens, favorite candy, a pocket tool. Adults don't need toys in their stocking.
What are good cheap stocking stuffers under $10?
Lip balm, gel pens, their favorite candy, gum, hair clips, stickers and small LEGO sets. Everything in the Under $10 section above fits.
How many stocking stuffers should I buy?
Three to six. Go by the size of the stocking and what your family normally does.
What should I avoid putting in Christmas stockings?
Plastic novelty stuff, makeup you're guessing on, and anything bought just to fill space. Check age limits on small toys and anything with a blade.
More Christmas gift guides
- Christmas gifts for mom
- Christmas gifts for dad
- Christmas gifts for grandma
- Christmas gifts for your boyfriend
- Christmas gifts for your girlfriend
- Christmas gifts for adult siblings
- Christmas gifts for in-laws
- Christmas gifts for parents who want nothing
- Christmas gifts for coworkers
- Christmas gifts for teachers
- Gifts for a new mom
- Stocking stuffers for men
- White elephant gifts
- Secret Santa gift ideas under $25
- What to get someone for Christmas
- Christmas gifts for your wife
- Christmas gifts for your husband

Remember the little things.
Giftin keeps their likes, dislikes and gift ideas in one place for next Christmas.
Download Giftin