Just coming for dinner? Bring a small host gift, around $15–$40. Exchanging presents? Check whether the family gives one gift per household or individual gifts before you shop.
Honestly, you don't have to impress the whole family on your first Christmas. A box of something they like, a restaurant they already go to, or one decent gift each is plenty.
If you're coming for Christmas dinner
You're a guest, so keep it simple. Bring something they can enjoy later, without having to stop cooking and deal with it.
Good butter shortbread
$15–$30Buttery, gift-wrapped, and they can open it whenever they like. The Walker's Assorted Shortbread box is listed at $20.99.
A small box of good truffles
$20–$40A small box of proper chocolates is an easy Christmas dinner gift. Go with dark or milk, whichever they actually eat.
Prices are rough US estimates. Check the shop before ordering.
A few other easy wins:
- Their usual coffee or tea, $15–$35. Get the exact brand they buy every week. No need to introduce them to some fancy roast.
- Pastries for the next morning, $20–$40. Especially good if you're staying over. Hand them over for tomorrow, when the Christmas dinner chaos is over.
- Flowers already in a vase, $30–$55. A nice arrangement is fine. A loose bouquet means someone who's busy cooking now has to find a vase and trim the stems.
If you're buying one gift for both in-laws
The safest move is something they already enjoy doing together. Don't buy them a new hobby and hope they get into it.
A gift card for their favorite restaurant
$60–$120Get them a gift card for the restaurant they keep going back to. They'll pick the evening, order what they like, and you won't have to guess.
Skip if They live separately. Buy individual gifts instead.
Other joint gifts worth considering:
- Two tickets to a show they've mentioned, $60–$150. Concert, theater, comedy, whatever they're into. If you can't confirm the date, get a venue gift certificate instead.
- A puzzle they'd actually finish, $20–$45. For people who already enjoy puzzles. If they usually do 500 pieces, don't surprise them with 2,000.
- A recent family photo, framed, $25–$65. One from a trip or celebration they haven't printed yet. Get a decent frame and it's done.
- Money toward something they're planning, from $30. A weekend away, a garden project, something they've talked about buying. Let them choose the details.
If everyone exchanges individual gifts
You don't need two amazing presents. Just find out one thing each person actually enjoys and buy around that.
Garden center gift card
$25–$60If they're always working in the garden, this one's easy. They can pick the plants and supplies they actually need when the season comes around.
Skip if They only keep houseplants and don't garden outdoors.
More ideas based on what they're into:
- The reader: bookshop credit or a book they mentioned, $20–$50. If they've named a specific title, get that one. Otherwise, let them choose.
- The home cook: a favorite ingredient, $20–$50. The olive oil, spice or specialty ingredient they already love using. Don't gamble on another kitchen gadget.
- The crossword regular: a puzzle book, $10–$25. Get one from the newspaper or publisher they normally use, at their usual difficulty.
- The movie lover: two cinema tickets, $25–$50. At their local theater, with someone of their choice.
- The one who says they don't need anything: lunch together, $30–$70. Somewhere they like, with two possible dates. You're paying.
And stick to the family limit. If everyone's spending $30, showing up with a $150 present just makes things awkward.

Save their favorite shops, gift ideas and what you gave them this year. Next Christmas, it's already there.
Get Giftin freeIf it's your first Christmas with them
You've only met them once or twice. Don't overthink it. A modest host gift or one shared present is enough.
You're staying for several days. Check if the family expects host gifts on top of Christmas presents. You don't want to buy twice when nobody else does.
Your partner says they're impossible to shop for. Find out what they do on a normal weekend. Maybe they go to the same café, follow a team or spend every Sunday gardening.
Money's tight this year. A $20 bakery box and a nice card are completely fine. You don't need to spend big to make a good impression.
There are stepparents or several households. Get a proper list of who's exchanging gifts with whom before you buy anything.
How much to spend on in-laws
There honestly ain't no single right amount. If it's your first Christmas with them, these are reasonable starting points.
But go with whatever the family normally does. If there's a $25 limit or everyone's doing Secret Santa, that's your budget.
Need to work out the rest of your Christmas spending? Our Christmas gift budget guide can help.
If you're shipping their gifts
For the contiguous US, USPS recommends sending by December 17, 2026 for Ground Advantage or December 18 for Priority Mail to arrive before Christmas. Those are recommended dates, not guarantees, so give yourself extra time for personalized gifts and check the USPS holiday shipping dates.
Quick answers
Should I buy separate gifts for my mother-in-law and father-in-law?
Only if that's how their family exchanges gifts. If they live together and enjoy the same things, one shared present is absolutely fine.
Is a gift card too impersonal for in-laws?
No. A gift card for the restaurant they love or the garden center they visit every weekend is a pretty solid gift.
What if my partner won't help me choose?
Try asking what their parents got last Christmas and whether they liked it. Still nothing? Keep it modest and go with something familiar.
More Christmas gift guides
- Christmas gifts for mom
- Christmas gifts for dad
- Christmas gifts for grandma
- Christmas gifts for your boyfriend
- Christmas gifts for your girlfriend
- Christmas gifts for adult siblings
- Christmas gifts for parents who want nothing
- Christmas gifts for coworkers
- Christmas gifts for teachers
- Gifts for a new mom
- Stocking stuffer ideas under $10
- Stocking stuffers for men
- White elephant gifts
- Secret Santa gift ideas under $25
- What to get someone for Christmas
- Christmas gifts for your wife
- Christmas gifts for your husband

Remember what they actually like.
Save their favorite shops, gift ideas and what you gave them this year. Next Christmas, it's already there.
Download Giftin